Prepared forMatt Orley and Joey Ruocco, Red CottageOctober 23, 2026
Appendix · Revenue Opportunity Snapshot

The 95 same-store homes.

Every year-over-year figure in the snapshot is built on these homes only: each hosted a paying guest before January 1, 2025 and again on or after September 30, 2026, so both years are full seasons in service. Acquired, launched or exited homes are excluded. Rent is January through September guest rent before OTA commission, excluding cleaning fees and taxes, from the Beyond export.

Same-store list

95 homes, $3,603,148 to $4,026,914, +11.8%.

HomeSubmarketBRJan to Sep 2025Jan to Sep 2026Change
Artist's Edge$10,825$4,895-55%
Belleayre BarnWestern Catskills3$44,335$31,609-29%
Belleayre ViewWestern Catskills3$38,345$54,589+42%
Birch & Buck$134,472$148,230+10%
Blue Mountain CabinEastern Catskills4$40,076$38,476-4%
Brookside ManorSouthern Catskills4$15,780$18,633+18%
Casa MagdaNorthern Catskills4$37,540$41,883+12%
Casa ManzaraHudson Valley5$118,882$112,912-5%
Cedar Brook CabinMaine2$25,181$20,273-19%
Chalet des CollinesBerkshires4$49,605$45,469-8%
Chestnut Ridge CabinVermont3$15,265$18,126+19%
Clancy HouseEastern Catskills4$36,840$33,984-8%
Coal CabinEastern Catskills2$17,979$19,199+7%
Derry Woods CabinVermont3$28,145$24,839-12%
DoodletwnLdgeCABNHudson Valley4$23,340$36,605+57%
DoodletwnLdgeFULLHudson Valley9$80,575$47,944-40%
DoodletwnLdgeMAINBerkshires5$57,563$109,180+90%
Falls RoadHudson Valley5$67,421$105,960+57%
Fern HollowLivingston Manor2$15,753$23,565+50%
Five Acres FarmSouthern Catskills5$12,247$9,566-22%
Fulton HouseSouthern Catskills4$18,944$25,273+33%
Grove HouseSouthern Catskills3$22,841$19,946-13%
Half Moon Mtn HouseSouthern Catskills4$21,743$20,819-4%
Hamlin HouseSouthern Catskills5$8,770$4,526-48%
Hemlock CliffhouseSouthern Catskills3$42,043$56,046+33%
Hemlock Hill BarnSouthern Catskills3$17,456$19,322+11%
Hidden PondEastern Catskills3$49,716$41,309-17%
Hidden RidgeSouthern Catskills4$49,817$56,869+14%
Highland HausVermont3$61,397$58,518-5%
Hillside HavenBerkshires4$29,104$45,546+56%
HilltopHudson Valley4$61,368$71,767+17%
Hudson Valley HideawHudson Valley5$42,016$58,412+39%
Hudson VictorianHudson Valley2$16,151$15,567-4%
Kaaterskill MtnHunter5$14,993$24,112+61%
Knickerbocker KnollSouthern Catskills3$19,381$18,790-3%
Kripplebush HollowEastern Catskills3$22,800$20,836-9%
Le Petit CottageEastern Catskills3$28,169$21,630-23%
Lilac HillSouthern Catskills4$17,888$23,762+33%
Little RiverSouthern Catskills2$46,860$39,553-16%
Malden Sur HudsonEastern Catskills4$24,027$31,873+33%
Meadow Top CottaBerkshires3$45,996$21,120-54%
Meeker Hill HouseBerkshires3$43,627$60,129+38%
Milan Hill AFrameHudson Valley4$32,325$46,733+45%
Mohawk Mountain RetrBerkshires5$7,078$46,275+554%
Moon Meadow FarmhsMaine5$83,818$81,883-2%
Mountaintop LOFTVermont1$21,899$18,525-15%
Mountaintop VIEWStowe3$11,587$38,883+236%
Myers RidgeSouthern Catskills5$35,431$25,414-28%
Narrowsburg ChaletSouthern Catskills3$13,157$19,013+45%
Nature’s EdgeSouthern Catskills3$21,080$23,327+11%
NavywoodHudson Valley3$20,824$26,471+27%
Nordic CabinHudson Valley3$17,300$23,598+36%
Onyx A FrameNorthern Catskills3$33,675$24,306-28%
Overlook MeadowCatskills3$46,477$53,605+15%
Owl BrookVermont4$24,300$32,100+32%
Owl's Perch$14,798$16,486+11%
Phoebe's Nest$20,707$8,772-58%
Post HausVermont2$40,574$48,778+20%
Rad Studio$61,454$60,778-1%
Red Rock SummitHudson Valley4$87,624$102,154+17%
Reservoir HouseWestern Catskills3$2,349$6,734+187%
River CottageBerkshires3$48,107$61,439+28%
Riverside Cabin FULLSouthern Catskills6$15,453$21,083+36%
Rock 'n' House$94,013$84,490-10%
Rockwell HausVermont5$35,829$33,392-7%
Silver Birch DOWNVermont4$8,781$6,804-23%
Silver RidgeHudson Valley4$36,661$32,114-12%
Sleepy Hollow LakeHudson Valley3$18,755$16,415-12%
Spirit CabinEastern Catskills3$139,027$150,279+8%
Spruce Cove CabinMaine2$38,382$32,795-15%
Steepletop LodgeBerkshires4$20,772$14,459-30%
Stonebridge HideawayCatskills3$9,376$2,791-70%
Stowe WoodsChaletStowe4$21,717$75,814+249%
Sugar Mountain HouseHudson Valley4$25,172$39,127+55%
Sunflower FarmhouseCatskills6$53,510$57,326+7%
Tamarack HouseSouthern Catskills2$25,703$25,919+1%
Tanner FarmhouseHudson Valley3$25,378$22,023-13%
The Aster ChaletVermont4$21,505$31,484+46%
The Barn @DoodletownHudson Valley4$27,322$16,212-41%
The GablesSouthern Catskills8$29,627$42,020+42%
The Homestead - FullSouthern Catskills14$32,421$60,005+85%
The Homestead MainSouthern Catskills11$50,560$24,060-52%
The Iron Ore CabinHudson Valley3$23,911$20,036-16%
The Rye HouseEastern Catskills4$83,909$113,019+35%
The TreehausVermont3$57,453$53,043-8%
Trail's End$20,469$26,059+27%
Valley ViewHudson Valley5$84,918$95,039+12%
West Kill FarmhouseNorthern Catskills5$107,422$122,319+14%
Whimsy WoodsHudson Valley4$140,052$130,868-7%
Wildcat Mtn CabinEastern Catskills2$21,788$28,637+31%
Willow BrookHudson Valley4$23,762$28,283+19%
Winterberry FarmhVermont4$38,398$44,493+16%
Woodland ManorSouthern Catskills3$7,295$15,385+111%
WoodlandsEastern Catskills3$4,637$6,499+40%
ZenbrookStowe4$39,331$87,681+123%

Submarket and bedroom count come from the PriceLabs listing record; a blank means the Beyond listing name did not match a PriceLabs listing. Homes are matched across Beyond and PriceLabs on a normalized name with channel suffixes removed.

Back to the snapshot.

The full Revenue Opportunity Snapshot, with the four opportunities and the first homes we would start on.

Open the snapshot